Thu 22 Apr 2010
Tool Saturation
Posted by kenneth under Tools
[8] Comments
Behold, the formerly vast expanses of my desk.
It’s pretty cool to sit here, toiling away, and glance over at my planes, thinking of what I’d much rather be doing. It’s a bit torturous at times, but it’s better than carefully stuffing my beautiful toys into a box. I consider it character.
I’ve bought and made a lot of stuff. I am on the verge of having too much stuff, partially because of my space limitations. While I’m not naive enough to think that there won’t be more stuff in the future, I’m not… you know… on the prowl anymore.
Don’t get me wrong, I likes the tools. I want one of each kind of hand plane that I could stand to maintain. I want at least one more size of combo square. I want every chisel that Lie-Nielsen makes. I want a lot more clamps. I want a spill plane in case I’m ever lost in a cave without any batteries for my flashlight—and happen to have one in my backpack, along with some scrap wood.
I’ve spent a lot of time perusing catalogs. I’ve seen lots of funky and interesting one-off tools, and jigs a-plenty. For a while now, it has been a constant barrage of Stuff. So many options, so many colors—I must leave here with something.
But I really don’t need any of it.
Maybe my enthusiasm is on hiatus because I’m so busy. I like to think it’s because my space limitations have helped me to think in terms of compactness and multi-purpose-ness, to plan ahead, and to set my stuff limit much lower than most. As it stands, I have a decent, yet humble, arsenal. Everything else just increases efficiency.
Then again, maybe I just ran out of space and my subconscious is taking the high road.

I like your arsenal. I love the photo. I think I will have to ‘StumbleUpon’ this, just for the beautiful picture.
Great post, Kenneth. Great photo too.
I think most woodworkers move past the ‘what am I going to buy next’ phase and start thinking more in terms of needs than wants. I’ve always been one to work with a spartan set of hand tools, taking some misguided pride in using old, refurbished tools that cost me a pittance. But I still lust after this or that tool on occasion. It’s in our blood.
Cheers — Larry
Nice set of Planes. I just recently purchased a couple and am learning to use them. They are awesome.
It’s true Larry. I thought I was going to be a tool-magnet type, but it turns out that I was just gearing up. I suppose that the power tool folks have lots more gear to -up, and that’s a stronger current to have to swim against.
Grover, planes are one of the things that make this fun for me. Good stuff.
Thanks Brian!
As someone still in the gearing up phase, but not interested in being a tool rehabber or collector (I’d rather make furniture), I get paralyzed by which tools I *need*, which would be useful, and which are totally unnecessary. Jack plane? Definitely! Side rabbet plane? Probably not. Shoulder plane? Hmm …
It depends on what you’re into. You could surely trim your shoulders with a chisel, but it would be more difficult to get them perfectly level without the registration that you get using the plane. Some people might use pocket screws as much as possible, or only do dovetailed boxes, so their needs would be different.I made a lot of basic stuff with just a jack and a shooting board, but when I started designing more grooves into my work, I got a plow plane. When I started designing more tenons in, a shoulder plane. I hit a different plateau at some point.
I think it’s a matter of planning your attack.
Kenneth,
This too shall pass. I’m in the same frame of mind given current financials and (more importantly) shop space & time. I’ve been through this cycle many times before and I know that when I get a few more shop hours (or square foot or dollars) my tool lust will return. Enjoy your current plateau and it’s financial reprieve as long as you can. Once the tool lust returns, have fun with your new toys.
Also, if your wife hasn’t read Kari’s 10 tips for Wives of Woodworkers, it’s high time she did. I read it to my wife this morning and it brought some much needed humor and insight.
http://villagecarpenter.blogspot.com/2009/11/vcs-top-ten-tips-for-wives-of.html